1. Tim McGraw
2. Picture To Burn
3. Teardrops On My Guitar
4. A Place in This World
5. Cold as You
6. The Outside
7. Tied Together with a Smile
8. Stay Beautiful
9. Should've Said No
10. Mary's Song (Oh My My My)
11. Our Song
12. I'm Only Me When I'm With You
13. Invisible
14. A Perfectly Good Heart

Digital edition (bonus track)

12. I Heart ?

Enhanced edition (bonus videos)

1. Tim McGraw
2. Taylor's Grand Ole Opry Debut

2008 reissue edition (bonus tracks)

12. I'm Only Me When I'm With You
13. Invisible
14. A Perfectly Good Heart
15. Teardrops On My Guitar (pop version)

2008 reissue enhanced edition (bonus videos)

1. Tim McGraw
2. Teardrops On My Guitar

Deluxe edition (bonus tracks)

12. I'm Only Me When I'm With You
13. Invisible
14. A Perfectly Good Heart
15. Taylor Swift's 1st Phone Call with Tim McGraw

Deluxe edition (bonus DVD)

1. Tim McGraw (music video)
2. Tim McGraw (Live at Grand Ole Opry)
3. Tim McGraw (Live at Yahoo! Music)
4. Teardrops On My Guitar (music video)
5. Teardrops On My Guitar (behind the scenes)
6. Our Song (music video)
7. Our Song (behind the scenes)
8. A Place In This World (GAC Short Cut series)
9. Picture to Burn (CMT's unplugged at 330 sessions video performance)
10. Taylor's Home Movie

Target deluxe edition (bonus DVD)

11. Taylor's Performance on the Tim McGraw and Faith Hill Tour 2007